Politicians are notorious for making promises they can’t keep. But they really outdid themselves in Illinois — and now the state is paying for it.
Illinois is on the verge of becoming America’s first state with a junk credit rating. The financial mess is the inevitable result of spending more on pensions and services than the state could afford — then covering it up with reckless budget tricks.
After decades of historic mismanagement, Illinois is now grappling with $15 billion of unpaid bills and an unthinkable quarter-trillion dollars owed to public employees when they retire.
The budget crisis has forced Illinois to jack up property taxes so high that people are leaving in droves. Illinois may soon have to take the unprecedented step of cutting off sales of lottery tickets because the state won’t be able to pay winners.
It will get worse if lawmakers can’t reach a budget compromise by Friday. This would be the third year in a row that America’s fifth-largest state has failed to pass a constitutionally required budget.
“Illinois got to this financially treacherous place by ignoring the long-term consequences of short-term decision-making,” said Laurence Msall, the president of Civic Federation, a budget watchdog organization.
The budget crisis has crippled social services that survive on state money, hurting everything from mental health services and Meals on Wheels for homebound seniors to domestic violence support centers.
“The most vulnerable citizens in Illinois are being hurt the most severely,” Msall said.
$251 billion pension time bomb
While the budget impasse is throwing a spotlight on Illinois’s dire financial situation today, the fiscal problems go back at least to the 1980s and involve politicians from both parties.
The most glaring evidence is the enormous pension crisis. Rather than dealing with the problem, Illinois continued to reward the state’s powerful unions with more generous benefits.
The problem festered for so long that Moody’s estimates Illinois has unfunded pension liabilities totaling $251 billion. To put that into context, that’s more than the combined market value of four major Illinois companies: Boeing, Caterpillar, United Continental and Allstate.
“The massive pension liability results from a chronic tendency to defer difficult decisions,” said Ted Hampton, who as a senior credit officer at Moody’s will help decide whether to downgrade Illinois into junk.
Hampton said Illinois treated the pension fund as a “financial cushion” that could be relied on to provide fiscal relief. He also pointed to a tendency to delay paying bills and chronically underestimate spending needs.
“All of these problems are governance and management weaknesses,” Hampton said.
That’s a polite way of saying the political leaders broke the system.
Missed opportunity in 1995
Experts said the turning point may have been 1995. At that point, Illinois already had one of the worst-funded pension systems in the United States. State leaders took action by adopting a 50-year plan to get the pension plans 90% funded.
But that plan turned out to be badly flawed. The initial contributions were too modest, and Illinois didn’t make the politically difficult choices of tax hikes or spending cuts to get the budget on a sustainable path.
“It was one of the greatest pieces of chicanery ever pulled by a political system,” said Ralph Martire, executive director at the Center for Tax and Budget Accountability, a think tank that promotes social and economic justice.
Instead of reform, the compromise “codified the practice of underfunding the pension” and “intentionally” grew the shortfall by $45 billion, Martire said.
Illinois is also notorious for using one-time financial tricks that masked the scale of its growing fiscal problems.
“Republicans and Democrats would stand up and say they passed a balanced budget, but it wasn’t — and they knew it,” said Diana Rickert, vice president of communications at the Illinois Policy Institute, a free market-oriented think tank.
Rickert said either the politicians knew what they were doing, or they “don’t know how math works.”
Lately, Illinois has been unable to reach a budget deal at all. Illinois has the distinction of being the first state ever to operate without a budget for more than a year, according to Msall.
“Unfortunately, the gimmicks that have worked in the recent past are not sufficient enough to make up the gaping hole that exists now,” Msall said.
Problems could ‘snowball’ from here
Illinois Republican Governor Bruce Rauner said on Thursday that if lawmakers fail to send a “balanced budget package” to his desk by Friday he will have “no choice but to keep them in session until they get the job done.”
That threat may not be enough to prevent Illinois from becoming America’s first “junk” state. Moody’s and S&P Global Ratings have indicated that failure to reach a budget deal will likely trigger a downgrade of Illinois’s debt below investment grade. That means a downgrade could come any day.
Getting cut to junk could make things even worse because it signals a heightened risk of default. Illinois’s borrowing costs would probably go even higher, which would only make the budget problems worse.
There’s always the chance of a last-minute credible deal, but few are holding out much hope.
“I don’t know that Illinois is going to get its act together in days after literally decades of being irresponsible,” said Rickert.
