North Carolina lawmakers on Thursday passed a bill that repeals the state’s controversial bathroom law in a move meant to end a year of tumult that saw businesses leave and major sporting events and concerts canceled.
But fierce criticism remains from LGBTQ groups, which say the new bill — which eliminates rules about who can use which restroom but retains other features — still allows for discrimination against transgender people.
The bill — a compromise agreed to Wednesday by Democratic Gov. Roy Cooper and the state’s top two Republican legislators — was approved by the House and Senate after contentious debate. It now goes to Cooper’s desk.
It wasn’t known when he would sign it.
Nor was it immediately clear whether organizations that opposed the outgoing bathroom law — such as the NCAA — would be satisfied and consider restoring events and other ventures in the state.
“Nobody is 100% happy, but I will say I’m 95% happy,” House Speaker Tim Moore, a Republican who backed the compromise.
What the new bill does
— It repeals last year’s House Bill 2. That bill had required that people at a government-run facility must use bathrooms and locker rooms that correspond to the gender on their birth certificate, if the rooms in question are multiple-occupancy.
— It effectively maintains a key feature of HB2 by leaving regulation of bathroom access solely in control of the Legislature.
— It prevents local governments, until December 2020, from passing or amending their own non-discrimination ordinances relating to private employment and public accommodation.
That last point is meant to prevent ordinances such as one Charlotte City Council passed in February 2016, before HB2. That ordinance added gender identity to the city’s protections against discrimination in public accommodations, and allowed transgender people to use the bathroom that matches the gender they identify with.
State lawmakers introduced HB2 a month later, in part to wipe out the Charlotte ordinance.
Greg Wallace, a professor at Campbell Law School in Raleigh, told CNN that the bill effectively restores the status quo, pre-HB2 — with the exception of the stipulations.
LGBTQ groups, other critics are upset
A day after Cooper and Republican lawmakers announced the compromise, the Senate passed it 32-16; the House then voted 70-48.
LGBT groups and other HB2 critics criticized the deal, saying it’s a “repeal” in name only — with one advocate calling it “HB2.0.” Focusing on the two clauses that the compromise added back, they say the bill fails to protect transgender people from discrimination.
“Disappointed the #NCGA just voted for a bill which fails to end LGBT discrimination in a move to put basketball over civil rights. #ncpol,” the ACLU said on Twitter.
The basketball “reference” is a nod to the NCAA, which moved 2016-2017 championship events out of the state because of HB2 and said it would soon decide where 2018-2022 championships will be held.
That may have put pressure on North Carolina’s politicians to hammer out this week’s deal. Indeed, during debate on the House floor, several representatives said they thought their colleagues were inappropriately rushing the vote to satisfy the NCAA.
“If we could have props in here, I would take a basketball covered in money and roll it down the middle aisle there, because that’s what this is about — money and basketball,” state Rep. Carl Ford, a Republican, said before voting no on the repeal.
Chris Sgro, executive director of Equality NC, called the agreement a “shell piece of a legislation,” on which the LGBTQ groups had not been consulted.
“The initiative is not a repeal,” Sgro said. “It’s doubling down on the discrimination that HB2 exacts — it’s HB2.0. It doesn’t allow municipalities to protect people from discrimination ’til 2020.”
“It doesn’t do anything to better the lives of LGBT North Carolinians.”
Bill’s supporters
Moore, the House speaker, said the compromise ensures cities didn’t go “above and beyond” what the state was willing to mandate.
He said the bill puts North Carolina in line with federal guidelines and 30 other states. This should guarantee that entities such as the NBA and NCAA don’t treat North Carolina differently than they would any other state, he said.
Senate Leader Phil Berger has said that the prohibition against city discrimination ordinances until December 2020 was designed to “allow federal litigation to play out.”
Moore gave a further argument, saying the state didn’t need a patchwork of anti-discrimination laws.
“We’ve got until 2020 to work this out,” Moore said.
Cooper, the Democrat who beat incumbent Pat McCrory on a campaign of vowing to repealing the bathroom law, said before the votes that he supported the compromise.
“It’s not a perfect deal, but it repeals House Bill 2 and begins to repair our reputation,” the governor said.
HB2’s impact on North Carolina
The deal came after several other failed attempts over the past year. State leaders faced considerable economic pressure, because companies and organizations that opposed the law withdrew events from the state and called off job-expansion plans.
HB2 is estimated to have cost the state millions of dollars through the loss of jobs, businesses and consumer spending, though by one measure, the losses only amount to about 0.1% of the state’s total GDP.
The 2017 NBA All-Star Game, which was held in February, was moved from Charlotte to New Orleans. The NCAA relocated several college athletic championship events for the 2016-17 season over the law and implied five more years of tournaments are at stake if HB2 stands.
The NCAA stated last week that it had moved the championships “because of the cumulative impact HB2 had on local communities’ ability to assure a safe, healthy, discrimination free atmosphere for all those watching and participating in our events.”
“Absent any change in the law, our position remains the same regarding hosting current or future events in the state.”
This week, an NCAA sports committee is due to start deciding where the 2018-2022 championships will be held. This added deadline may have put more pressure on politicians to hammer out a last-minute deal on HB2.
Why NCAA left North Carolina
It remains to be seen how the NCAA will view the legislative action.
When the NCAA announced in September it was moving championship events out of North Carolina, it listed the following factors:
-North Carolina laws invalidate any local law that treats sexual orientation as a protected class or has a purpose to prevent discrimination against lesbian, gay, bisexual or transgender individuals.
North Carolina has the only statewide law that makes it unlawful to use a restroom different from the gender on one’s birth certificate, regardless of gender identity.
North Carolina law provides legal protections for government officials to refuse services to the LGBT community.
Five states plus numerous cities prohibit travel to North Carolina for public employees and representatives of public institutions, which could include student-athletes and campus athletics staff. These states are New York, Minnesota, Washington, Vermont and Connecticut.
